SynC · Editorial revision
Contract Modification Procedures
Revision1
EditedNov 16, 2026
StatusCurrent
Contents
- 1Scope
- 2Contract Modification Terms
- 3Referenced Standards
- 4Submittals
- 4.1Contract Modification Submittals
- 5Minor Changes in the Work
- 5.1Field Orders
- 6Proposal Requests and the Contractor's Proposal
- 6.1Issuance of a Proposal Request
- 6.2Response Time
- 6.3Content of the Change Proposal
- 6.4Review of the Change Proposal
- 7Contractor-Initiated Change Proposals
- 7.1Notice That Starts a Change Proposal
- 7.2Contractor's Proposal for a Change in Its Own Interest
- 8Pricing of Changes
- 8.1Cost Breakdown Required
- 8.2Labor and Material Cost
- 8.3Markups
- 8.4Equipment Rates
- 8.5Bond and Insurance Premium Adjustment
- 8.6Unit Prices
- 8.7Force Account
- 9Construction Change Directives
- 9.1When a Construction Change Directive Is Used
- 9.2Performance Under a Construction Change Directive
- 9.3Conversion to a Change Order
- 10Change Orders
- 10.1Content of a Change Order
- 10.2Contractor's Release in a Change Order
- 10.3Execution of a Change Order
- 10.4Allowance Adjustments
- 11Adjustment of the Contract Time
- 11.1Request for Extension
- 11.2Time Impact Analysis
- 11.3Concurrent Delay
- 11.4Weather Delay
- 12Notice of Claims and Differing Site Conditions
- 12.1Notice of a Claim
- 12.2Continuing Performance
- 12.3Hand-Off to the Dispute Resolution Procedure
- 12.4Notice of a Differing Site Condition
- 13Coordination with the Agreement and Other Standards
View changes in this revision Revision history
Current revision. This is editorial revision 1, the current text of this standard. Read it on the standard's page.
New standard for changing the Contract after award: minor changes, proposal requests and the Contractor's proposal, Contractor-initiated change proposals, how a change is priced (cost breakdown, markups, equipment rates, unit prices, force account), construction change directives, change orders, adjustment of the Contract Time, and notice of claims and differing site conditions.
1 Scope
NOTE This standard establishes the administrative procedure for modifying the Contract after award: how a change in the Work is requested, proposed, priced, directed, and executed, how a request for an extension of the Contract Time is supported, and what notice the Contractor gives to preserve a claim or to report a differing site condition, on any project and under any Division of the Specifications. (1.1)
NOTE The right of the Owner to order a change, the Contractor's entitlement to an adjustment of the Contract Sum or the Contract Time, and the procedure for resolving a dispute originate in the Agreement and the General Conditions, which are contract instruments, not specifications. This standard adds the paperwork on top of those rights: the forms, the response times, the content of a proposal, the cost breakdown, the markups, the schedule analysis, and the notice periods that the General Conditions leave to the project manual. Where a conflict appears between this standard and the executed Agreement, General Conditions, or Supplementary Conditions, those instruments govern, and this standard fills only the gaps they leave open. (1.2)
NOTE A change that is priced one way on the first change order and another way on the tenth is the change the parties argue about at closeout. Stating the pricing rules and the notice periods once, before the first change, is what lets every change on the project be checked against the same page, by a subcontractor who never saw the General Conditions as readily as by the Engineer. (1.3)
1.4 The Contractor shall comply with this standard in addition to any change, claim, or notice requirement stated in the Agreement, the General Conditions, or a technical standard.
1.5 Where a requirement of this standard conflicts with the Agreement, the General Conditions, or the Supplementary Conditions, those instruments shall govern.
1.6 Where a technical standard requires the Contractor to report a condition, propose an alternative, or request a change, the report, proposal, or request shall be made under the procedure of this standard.
NOTE The following are outside the scope of this standard: (1.7)
- The Owner's right to order changes, the Contractor's entitlement to an adjustment, the ownership of float, concurrent delay, and the dispute resolution procedure, which the Agreement and the General Conditions govern
- Payment for an approved change through the applications for payment, the revision of the schedule of values for it, the adjustment of an allowance, and the measurement and payment of unit-price Work, which Payment ProceduresPayment ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/payment-procedures governs
- The evaluation and acceptance of a substitution as a product decision, which Product RequirementsProduct RequirementsResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/product-requirements governs, and which reaches this standard only when an accepted substitution changes the Contract Sum or the Contract Time
- The request for information, which Project Management And CoordinationProject Management and CoordinationResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/project-management-and-coordination governs, and which is not a request for a change
- The adjustment of the bond penal sums for a change in the Contract Sum, which Warranties And BondsWarranties and BondsResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/warranties-and-bonds governs
- The format, content, submittal, and updating of the construction schedule, which Construction Progress DocumentationConstruction Progress DocumentationResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/construction-progress-documentation governs and on which every time impact analysis under this standard is run
- The geotechnical investigation and response once a differing subsurface condition has been noticed, which EarthworkEarthworkResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/earthwork governs
- The prompt payment, retainage, and procurement provisions of the law of the jurisdiction of the project, which apply regardless of anything in this standard
2 Contract Modification Terms
NOTE The following terms are used in this standard with the meanings given here: (2.1)
- A proposal request is a written request from the Owner or the Engineer that the Contractor state the cost and time effect of a described change, and it is not an order to perform the change
- A change proposal is the Contractor's written statement of the cost and time effect of a change, whether made in response to a proposal request or on the Contractor's own initiative
- A minor change in the Work is a change that is consistent with the intent of the Contract Documents and involves no adjustment of the Contract Sum or the Contract Time, which the Engineer may order within the authority the General Conditions give it
- A field order is the written instrument by which the Engineer orders a minor change in the Work, by whatever name the General Conditions give it
- A construction change directive is the written instrument by which the Owner directs a change in the Work before the adjustment of the Contract Sum or the Contract Time for it has been agreed, by whatever name the General Conditions give it, including a work change directive or an interim directed change
- A change order is the written instrument, signed by the Owner and the Contractor and prepared or acknowledged by the Engineer, that changes the Work, the Contract Sum, the Contract Time, or any of them, and records the parties' agreement on the adjustment
- An allowance adjustment is the change order that reconciles an allowance stated in the Contract Documents against the cost of the Work performed under it
- Force account is the pricing of a change on the basis of the actual cost of labor, material, and equipment, recorded daily and marked up as this standard provides, used where the parties have not agreed a price
- A time impact analysis is a schedule analysis that inserts the delaying event into the current accepted schedule and measures its effect on the critical path and the completion date
- A claim is a written demand by the Contractor or the Owner for an adjustment of the Contract Sum or the Contract Time, or for another relief under the Contract, on which the parties have not agreed
- A differing site condition is a subsurface or concealed physical condition at the site that differs materially from the conditions the Contract Documents indicate, or an unknown physical condition of an unusual nature that differs materially from the conditions ordinarily encountered in work of the character provided for
3 Referenced Standards
3.1 The modification of the Contract shall comply with the latest adopted edition of each of the following unless a specific edition is cited or the Contract Documents direct otherwise.
3.2 Where referenced documents conflict, the more stringent requirement shall govern unless the Engineer of Record directs otherwise in writing.
| Standard | Title |
|---|---|
| AIA A201 | General Conditions of the Contract for Construction (Article 7, changes in the Work; Article 15, claims and disputes) |
| AIA G701 | Change Order |
| AIA G709 | Proposal Request |
| AIA G714 | Construction Change Directive |
| EJCDC C-700 | Standard General Conditions of the Construction Contract (changes in the Work; claims) |
| EJCDC C-940 | Work Change Directive |
| EJCDC C-941 | Change Order |
| EJCDC C-942 | Field Order |
| ConsensusDocs 200 | Standard Agreement and General Conditions Between Owner and Constructor |
| ConsensusDocs 202 | Change Order |
| AACE International RP 29R-03 | Forensic Schedule Analysis |
| AACE International RP 52R-06 | Time Impact Analysis, As Applied in Construction |
NOTE The general conditions in common use each provide for a change ordered by the Owner without agreement on price, for a minor change by the Engineer, and for a change order recording agreement, under names that differ from one publisher to the next. Each publisher also issues a form for each instrument, drafted to pair with its own general conditions. The forms cited here are examples of that pairing, and the form that matches the General Conditions on the project is the one whose definitions and signature blocks line up with them. The two AACE recommended practices describe the schedule analysis methods: 52R-06 describes the prospective time impact analysis this standard requires with a request for extension, and 29R-03 describes the retrospective methods a dispute falls back on when the prospective analysis was never done. (3.3)
4 Submittals
4.1 Contract Modification Submittals
4.1.1 The Contractor shall submit the following, each at the time this standard states for it:
- The change proposal, with its cost breakdown, in response to each proposal request and with each change the Contractor initiates
- The time impact analysis, with each request for an extension of the Contract Time
- The daily force-account records, for each day on which Work is performed under a construction change directive or on a force-account basis
- The notice of a differing site condition, within the period indicated in the datasheet after the condition is encountered
- The notice of a claim, within the period indicated in the datasheet after the event giving rise to it
- The executed change order, signed by the Contractor, returned within the period this standard sets for it
Contract Modification Submittals Requiredcheckbox
☑ Change proposal with cost breakdown
☑ Time impact analysis with each extension request
☑ Daily force-account records
☑ Notice of differing site condition
☑ Notice of claim
☑ Executed change order
4.1.2 Contract modification submittals shall be transmitted through the project communication platform under Project Management And CoordinationProject Management and CoordinationResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/project-management-and-coordination and logged in a change log the Contractor maintains, and shall not be transmitted through the shop drawing and product data register of Submittal And Quality ProceduresSubmittal and Quality ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/submittal-and-quality-procedures.
4.1.3 The change log shall list, for each proposal request, change proposal, field order, construction change directive, change order, and claim, its number, its date, its subject, its status, and the adjustment of the Contract Sum and the Contract Time it proposes or records.
NOTE A change proposal filed in the shop drawing log is reviewed as a shop drawing, which is to say for conformance, and the clock that matters on it, the response time and the notice period, is not tracked. A separate log, numbered in sequence for each instrument, is what lets the parties see at a meeting which changes are open, which are priced, and which are waiting on a signature. (4.1.4)
5 Minor Changes in the Work
5.1 Field Orders
5.1.1 The Engineer may order a minor change in the Work by a field order, within the authority the General Conditions give the Engineer, where the change is consistent with the intent of the Contract Documents and involves no adjustment of the Contract Sum or the Contract Time.
5.1.2 A field order shall be in writing, shall describe the change, and shall state that it involves no adjustment of the Contract Sum or the Contract Time.
5.1.3 The Contractor shall perform a field order on receipt.
5.1.4 Where the Contractor considers that a field order involves an adjustment of the Contract Sum or the Contract Time, the Contractor shall give written notice to the Engineer and the Owner, within the claim notice period indicated in the datasheet and before performing the ordered Work, stating the adjustment it considers due.
5.1.5 A field order the Contractor performs without the notice this article requires shall be a minor change in the Work, and no adjustment of the Contract Sum or the Contract Time shall be due for it.
NOTE The field order exists so that a hanger moved a foot, a conduit rerouted around a beam, or a color changed before the order is placed can be settled on site in writing, without a change order for a change that costs nothing. The notice requirement is what keeps it honest: a Contractor who thinks the change costs something says so before doing it, when the Engineer can withdraw the order or convert it to a proposal request, rather than after, when the only remedy is a claim. (5.1.6)
6 Proposal Requests and the Contractor's Proposal
6.1 Issuance of a Proposal Request
6.1.1 The Owner or the Engineer may issue a proposal request describing a proposed change in the Work, with the drawings, specifications, and other information needed to price it, and requesting the Contractor's change proposal.
6.1.2 A proposal request shall be numbered in sequence, shall state the date by which the change proposal is due, and shall state that it is not an authorization to proceed with the change.
6.1.3 A proposal request shall not authorize the Contractor to proceed with the described change, to order material for it, or to stop or alter Work affected by it, and the Contractor shall not do any of those things on the strength of a proposal request alone.
NOTE The proposal request is a question, and a Contractor who treats it as an order does work the Owner may decide not to buy. The one exception, where the Owner wants the work started before the price is agreed, is the construction change directive, which is a different instrument because it carries a different obligation. (6.1.4)
6.2 Response Time
6.2.1 The Contractor shall submit its change proposal within the period indicated in the datasheet after receiving a proposal request, or within the longer period the proposal request states.
Change Proposal Response Timerange
Not more than
days
5710142130
6.2.2 Where the Contractor cannot obtain a subcontractor's or supplier's quotation within the period, the Contractor shall submit, within the period, the change proposal for the parts it can price and a written statement of the parts outstanding and the date each is expected.
6.3 Content of the Change Proposal
6.3.1 Each change proposal shall describe the change, shall reference the proposal request or the notice that gave rise to it, and shall state the adjustment of the Contract Sum and of the Contract Time the Contractor proposes.
6.3.2 Each change proposal shall include the cost breakdown the Pricing of Changes section of this standard requires, at the level of detail that section states, for the Contractor's own Work and for each subcontractor's and supplier's Work.
6.3.3 Each change proposal shall state the effect of the change on the Contract Time and, where an extension is proposed, shall include the time impact analysis the Adjustment of the Contract Time section of this standard requires.
6.3.4 Each change proposal shall identify every other part of the Work the change affects, including Work already in place that would be removed or altered, and shall include the cost and time of that effect in the proposal.
6.3.5 Each change proposal shall state the period for which the proposed price remains open for acceptance, which shall be not less than thirty days after submittal unless the proposal states a reason the period cannot be held.
NOTE A change proposal that states a lump sum and nothing else cannot be checked, cannot be negotiated line by line, and cannot be compared with the Engineer's own estimate, which is why the breakdown is required with the proposal rather than on request. A proposal with no validity period is withdrawn the day the Owner accepts it, on the ground that a quotation inside it expired. (6.3.6)
6.4 Review of the Change Proposal
6.4.1 The Engineer shall review each change proposal, shall compare it with the Engineer's own estimate of the change, and shall recommend to the Owner acceptance, rejection, or negotiation of the proposal.
6.4.2 Where the Owner accepts a change proposal, the acceptance shall be recorded in a change order under this standard, and the Contractor shall not proceed with the change until the change order is executed or a construction change directive is issued.
6.4.3 Where the Owner rejects a change proposal, or does not act on it within its validity period, the Contractor shall not perform the proposed change and no adjustment shall be due for the cost of preparing the proposal.
NOTE The cost of preparing a change proposal is part of the Contractor's overhead, recovered through the markup on the changes that are accepted, and it is not a separate charge on the ones that are not. A proposal request the Owner issues and then withdraws costs the Contractor an estimate, which is the same thing a bid costs, and the Contract prices it the same way. (6.4.4)
7 Contractor-Initiated Change Proposals
7.1 Notice That Starts a Change Proposal
7.1.1 Where the Contractor considers that an instruction, an interpretation, a condition, an act or omission of the Owner or the Engineer, or any other event entitles it to an adjustment of the Contract Sum or the Contract Time, the Contractor shall give written notice to the Owner and the Engineer within the claim notice period indicated in the datasheet after the event, and before performing the Work the adjustment would cover, except where the General Conditions permit a later notice.
7.1.2 The notice shall identify the event, the date it occurred or was discovered, the provision of the Contract Documents under which the adjustment is claimed, and the general nature of the adjustment, and a precise amount shall not be required in the notice.
7.1.3 The notice under this article shall satisfy the notice of claim this standard requires, and a change proposal the Owner accepts after it shall resolve the claim the notice preserved.
NOTE The notice is short on purpose. It tells the Owner that a change is coming, while the Owner can still observe the condition, withdraw the instruction, or decide to do without, and it leaves the pricing to the proposal that follows. A notice that is not given in time loses the adjustment under most general conditions, whatever its merit, and the technical standards that require the Contractor to report a condition rely on this article to say how. (7.1.4)
7.2 Contractor's Proposal for a Change in Its Own Interest
7.2.1 The Contractor may propose a change in the Work in its own interest, including a change that reduces the Contract Sum or the Contract Time, by a change proposal that states the reason for the change and the adjustment the Contractor offers.
7.2.2 A change proposal that substitutes a product or a system for the one the Contract Documents specify shall first be accepted as a substitution under Product RequirementsProduct RequirementsResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/product-requirements, and shall reach this standard only for the change order that records its effect on the Contract Sum and the Contract Time.
NOTE A change proposed by the Contractor is accepted, when it is, because it saves the Owner money or time or improves the Work, and the proposal has to say which. The substitution route exists so that a product the Contractor would rather furnish is judged as a product first, by the engineer who specified the original, before anyone prices it. (7.2.4)
8 Pricing of Changes
8.1 Cost Breakdown Required
8.1.1 Each change proposal, each construction change directive settlement, and each force-account record shall price the change by a cost breakdown that states separately, for the Contractor's own Work and for the Work of each subcontractor and supplier at every tier:
- Labor, by trade, as the hours and the hourly rate for each classification, with the wage, the fringe benefits, the payroll taxes, and the workers' compensation and liability insurance that make up the rate stated separately
- Material, by item, as the quantity, the unit price, the extended amount, and the applicable sales tax, supported by the supplier's quotation or invoice
- Equipment, by unit, as the hours or days of use and the rate under the equipment rate basis indicated in the datasheet
- Subcontract Work, as the subcontractor's own breakdown to this same detail, with the subcontractor's markup stated separately from the Contractor's
- The markups this standard allows, each stated as a percentage applied to the stated base
- The bond and insurance premium adjustment, stated as a separate line
- Credits for Work deleted or reduced, priced to this same detail
8.1.2 A deductive change shall be priced at the same detail as an additive change, and a lump-sum credit without a breakdown shall not be accepted.
NOTE A breakdown to the same detail for a credit as for an addition is what prevents the recurring pattern of additions priced at list and deletions credited at cost. The subcontractor's own breakdown, rather than a one-line subcontract amount, is what lets the Engineer see where the money in a change actually is, which on most changes is two tiers down. (8.1.3)
8.2 Labor and Material Cost
8.2.1 The cost of labor shall be the actual cost of the workers performing the changed Work, including supervision at the foreman level and below, and shall not include the Contractor's superintendent, project manager, or home office staff, whose cost is recovered in the markup.
8.2.2 The cost of material shall be the actual cost delivered to the site, net of trade and quantity discounts received, including sales tax and freight, and the Contractor shall furnish the supplier's quotation or invoice on request.
8.2.3 Material the Contractor has already purchased for the deleted Work and cannot return shall be credited at its salvage value, and material it can return shall be credited at the purchase price less the restocking charge the supplier actually imposes.
8.2.4 Small tools, consumables, and expendable supplies shall be included in the markup on labor and shall not be charged as a separate item, unless the Supplementary Conditions provide a stated allowance for them.
8.3 Markups
8.3.1 The markup the Contractor may add to the direct cost of Work it performs with its own forces, covering overhead and profit, shall be the percentage indicated in the datasheet.
Markup on the Contractor's Own Workrange
Not more than
%
510152025
8.3.2 The markup the Contractor may add to the cost of Work performed by a subcontractor, covering the Contractor's overhead and profit on that Work, shall be the percentage indicated in the datasheet.
Markup on Subcontracted Workrange
Not more than
%
510152025
8.3.3 The markup a subcontractor at any tier may add to the direct cost of Work it performs with its own forces, covering its overhead and profit, shall be the percentage indicated in the datasheet, and a subcontractor's markup on the Work of a lower tier shall be the same percentage as the Contractor's markup on subcontracted Work.
Subcontractor's Markup on Its Own Workrange
Not more than
%
510152025
8.3.4 The markup shall cover every cost of the change not stated as a direct cost in the breakdown, including supervision above the foreman level, project management, home office overhead, small tools, temporary facilities, field office, estimating, scheduling, warranty, and profit, and no separate charge for any of them shall be allowed.
8.3.6 Where a change both adds and deletes Work, the markup shall be applied to the net change in direct cost.
8.3.7 The credit for deleted Work shall carry markup as indicated in the datasheet.
Markup Credited on Deleted Workradio
○ Direct cost only, no markup credited
○ Direct cost plus the same markup percentages as added Work
NOTE Crediting the direct cost only recognizes that the Contractor's overhead on the project does not fall when a room is deleted, and that the profit on the deleted Work was part of the price the Owner agreed to, and it is the position most general conditions take for a net decrease. Crediting the markup as well returns the Owner the full price it paid for the deleted Work, and it is the position an Owner takes where it expects to delete a large scope and does not want to pay overhead and profit on Work that will never be built. The choice matters most on a project with a deductive alternate held in reserve or a scope the Owner may cut after award. (8.3.8)
8.4 Equipment Rates
8.4.1 The rate for Contractor-owned equipment used on a change shall be determined on the basis indicated in the datasheet, and shall include the operating cost of fuel, lubricants, and routine maintenance unless the basis states them separately.
Equipment Rate Basisradio
○ The Contractor's actual ownership and operating cost, documented from its records
○ The prevailing local rental rate for equipment of the same class, documented by quotations
○ A published construction equipment cost reference named in the Supplementary Conditions
NOTE Actual ownership and operating cost is the truest measure and the hardest to audit, because it depends on the Contractor's depreciation schedule, its utilization, and records the Owner never sees. A prevailing rental rate is easy to check against two quotations and overstates the cost of equipment the Contractor already owns and would otherwise have idle. A published cost reference, with its regional adjustment and its stated allocation between ownership and operating cost, gives both parties a number neither can argue with, at the cost of adopting a schedule that may run above or below the local market in a given year, and the Supplementary Conditions name the reference and its edition so that the number is fixed at award. (8.4.2)
8.4.3 The rate for rented equipment shall be the actual invoiced rental, and the Contractor shall furnish the invoice on request.
8.4.4 Equipment shall be charged only for the time it is in use on the changed Work, and standby time shall be charged only where the Engineer has directed the equipment to stand by in writing, at the standby rate the equipment rate basis provides or, where it provides none, at one half of the operating rate without operating cost.
8.4.5 Hand tools and equipment with a replacement value below the threshold the Supplementary Conditions state, or where they state none, below five hundred dollars, shall be small tools and shall not be charged as equipment.
8.5 Bond and Insurance Premium Adjustment
8.5.2 The bond rider the surety requires when the aggregate increase in the Contract Sum crosses the threshold indicated in Warranties And BondsWarranties and BondsResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/warranties-and-bonds shall be furnished under that standard, and its cost shall be included in the change order that crosses the threshold.
8.6 Unit Prices
8.6.1 Where the Contract Documents state a unit price for an item of Work and the change adds or deletes a quantity of that item, the change shall be priced at the stated unit price, and the unit price shall include the Contractor's markup unless the Contract Documents state otherwise.
8.6.2 Where the quantity of a unit-price item changes by more than the percentage the General Conditions set, or where they set none, by more than twenty-five percent of the quantity stated in the Contract Documents, either party may request that the unit price be adjusted for the quantity actually performed, and the adjustment shall be made by change order on the cost breakdown this standard requires.
8.6.3 The measurement and payment of unit-price Work, including the quantities on which progress payment is made, shall be as Payment ProceduresPayment ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/payment-procedures provides.
NOTE A bid unit price is priced for the quantity in the bid, and it carries fixed costs of mobilization and setup spread over that quantity. Doubling the quantity makes the price generous and halving it makes the price a loss, which is why the general conditions in common use let either party reopen it past a stated swing, and the swing stated here applies only where the General Conditions are silent. (8.6.4)
8.7 Force Account
8.7.1 Where the Owner and the Contractor have not agreed a price for a change before the Work is performed, the change shall be priced on a force-account basis, as the actual cost of labor, material, and equipment under this section, plus the markups this standard allows.
8.7.2 The Contractor shall record, for each day on which Work is performed on a force-account basis, the workers by name, classification, and hours, the material incorporated by item and quantity, the equipment used by unit and hours, and the Work performed, on a daily force-account record.
8.7.3 The Contractor's superintendent and the Owner's or the Engineer's field representative shall each sign the daily force-account record at the end of each day it covers, and a signature shall attest to the hours, the quantities, and the equipment recorded and not to the entitlement to payment or the rate.
8.7.4 The Contractor shall submit the signed daily force-account records within seven days after the end of each week in which force-account Work is performed, with the supplier invoices and the equipment rates needed to price them.
8.7.5 A daily force-account record the Owner's or the Engineer's representative was not given the opportunity to sign on the day it covers, or that is submitted after the period this article sets, shall be evidence of the Work only to the extent the Engineer can verify it from other records.
NOTE The daily signature settles the facts while they can be seen: how many workers, which machine, how many hours. The rate and the entitlement are settled later, which is why the signature is limited to the facts, and why a representative who signs is not conceding the claim. A record produced at the end of the month, from memory, is what the daily signature exists to avoid, and the evidentiary rule is what gives the Contractor the reason to get the signature each day. (8.7.6)
9 Construction Change Directives
9.1 When a Construction Change Directive Is Used
9.1.1 The Owner may direct a change in the Work by a construction change directive where the Owner requires the change to proceed before the adjustment of the Contract Sum or the Contract Time has been agreed, or where the Owner and the Contractor have not agreed on the Contractor's change proposal.
9.1.2 A construction change directive shall be in writing, shall be signed by the Owner and the Engineer, shall describe the change, and shall state the basis on which the adjustment of the Contract Sum will be determined, as a lump sum the directive proposes, as unit prices stated in the Contract Documents or in the directive, as the cost under the Pricing of Changes section of this standard with its markups, or as the Engineer determines under the General Conditions.
9.1.3 A construction change directive shall state the adjustment of the Contract Time the Owner proposes, or that the adjustment will be determined on the Contractor's time impact analysis.
NOTE The directive is the instrument for the change that cannot wait: the bearing stratum found two feet low, the utility that is where the drawings said it was not, the Owner's program change discovered while the formwork is up. It commits the Owner to pay and the Contractor to proceed, and it leaves the amount to be settled by the records the Contractor keeps from the day it is issued. A directive used routinely, for changes that could have waited for a proposal, puts every change on the force-account footing that the proposal process exists to avoid. (9.1.4)
9.2 Performance Under a Construction Change Directive
9.2.1 The Contractor shall proceed with the Work a construction change directive describes on receipt of the directive, and shall sign the directive to acknowledge receipt within three days, and the Contractor's signature shall not signify agreement with the adjustment the directive proposes unless the directive so states and the Contractor so indicates.
9.2.2 Where the Contractor disagrees with the adjustment a construction change directive proposes, the Contractor shall state its disagreement in writing within the claim notice period indicated in the datasheet after receiving the directive, and shall nonetheless proceed with the directed Work.
9.2.3 The Contractor shall keep the daily force-account records the Pricing of Changes section of this standard requires for all Work performed under a construction change directive whose adjustment has not been agreed, from the first day of that Work, whether or not the directive states cost as the basis of adjustment.
NOTE Records kept from the first day are what let a directive be converted to a change order on evidence rather than on estimate, and they protect the Contractor as much as the Owner, since a Contractor who disputes the Owner's lump sum and kept no records has nothing to dispute it with. (9.2.4)
9.3 Conversion to a Change Order
9.3.1 Where the Owner and the Contractor agree on the adjustment of the Contract Sum and the Contract Time for a construction change directive, the agreement shall be recorded in a change order within thirty days after the agreement.
9.3.2 Where the Owner and the Contractor do not agree on the adjustment, the Engineer shall determine it under the General Conditions on the records this standard requires, the determination shall be recorded in a change order, and the party that does not accept the determination shall preserve its position by the reservation the Change Orders section of this standard provides or by a claim under this standard.
9.3.3 Payment for Work performed under a construction change directive before its conversion to a change order shall be made through the applications for payment as Payment ProceduresPayment ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/payment-procedures provides for that Work.
NOTE A directive that is never converted leaves the Contract Sum and the Contract Time unstated for the rest of the project, and every later schedule analysis and every later payment application carries the uncertainty. The thirty days exist so that directives are closed while the records are fresh and the people who signed them are still on the project. (9.3.4)
10 Change Orders
10.1 Content of a Change Order
10.1.1 Each change order shall be numbered in sequence, shall be on the Owner's form or on a published form such as those cited in the Referenced Standards section of this standard, and shall identify the Contract, the proposal request, change proposal, field order, construction change directive, or claim it resolves, and the date.
10.1.2 Each change order shall describe the change in the Work in enough detail that a reader who has not seen the proposal can identify the Work added, deleted, or altered, and shall attach or reference the drawings and specifications that define it.
10.1.3 Each change order shall state the adjustment of the Contract Sum as a dollar amount, the Contract Sum before the change order, the net change by all previous change orders, and the Contract Sum as adjusted by the change order.
10.1.4 Each change order shall state the adjustment of the Contract Time in calendar days, or that there is none, and the date of substantial completion as adjusted by the change order.
10.1.5 Each change order shall identify, by reference to the Contract Documents and to the schedule of values under Payment ProceduresPayment ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/payment-procedures, the line items the adjustment is to be added to or deducted from.
NOTE A change order that states a dollar amount and no time is read as an agreement that the change took no time, and one that states a time and no revised completion date leaves the completion date to be computed by whoever reads it next. The running totals on the face of the change order are what let the thirtieth change order be checked without reading the twenty-nine before it. (10.1.6)
10.2 Contractor's Release in a Change Order
10.2.1 The Contractor's agreement to a change order shall constitute the release indicated in the datasheet with respect to the change the change order covers.
Contractor's Release in a Change Orderradio
○ Full release of every cost and time impact of the change, including impact on unchanged Work
○ Release of the impacts stated in the change order, with reservation of the impacts the Contractor identifies on its face
NOTE A full release settles the change for good: the amount and the days on the change order are the whole adjustment, and the Contractor cannot return later with a claim that the change disrupted the unchanged Work, consumed float, or compounded with other changes. It gives the Owner certainty and costs the Contractor the ability to recover an impact it could not see at the time, which the Contractor prices into every change or refuses to sign until it can see the whole effect. A release with a reservation lets the Contractor sign the change order for the direct cost and keep open the impacts it names, such as the cumulative effect of many changes on productivity or a time extension it cannot yet quantify, and it costs the Owner a change order that does not close the change. Under either option a reservation that is not stated on the face of the change order is not preserved. (10.2.2)
10.2.3 Where a reservation is permitted and the Contractor reserves an impact, the Contractor shall state on the face of the change order the impact reserved and the period within which it will submit the claim for it, and a reservation stated only in a transmittal or a cover letter shall have no effect.
10.2.4 A change order that states no reservation on its face shall be a full release of the change it covers, regardless of the release indicated in the datasheet.
10.3 Execution of a Change Order
10.3.1 Each change order shall be signed by the Owner and by the Contractor, and shall be prepared, recommended, or acknowledged by the Engineer as the General Conditions provide.
10.3.2 The Contractor shall sign and return a change order the Owner has executed within ten days after receiving it, or shall state in writing within that period the respect in which the change order does not record the agreement reached.
10.3.3 Where the Owner's governing body, a lender, or a funding authority must approve a change order before it binds the Owner, the change order shall so state, and it shall take effect on that approval.
10.3.4 A change order shall take effect, and the Contractor may proceed with the change it covers, when it has been signed by the Owner and the Contractor and any approval it states has been given, and not before.
10.3.5 Where the change order follows a construction change directive, the Contractor shall continue the directed Work during the execution of the change order.
10.3.6 The Contractor shall furnish, with the first application for payment after a change order takes effect, the revised schedule of values and the schedule update that Payment ProceduresPayment ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/payment-procedures and Construction Progress DocumentationConstruction Progress DocumentationResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/construction-progress-documentation require for it.
NOTE A public Owner's change order above its board's threshold is not a change order until the board votes, and a Contractor who proceeds on the staff's signature proceeds at its own risk. Saying so on the form is what tells the Contractor which signature is the last one. (10.3.7)
10.4 Allowance Adjustments
10.4.1 The reconciliation of each allowance stated in the Contract Documents against the cost of the Work performed under it shall be recorded in a change order under this standard, on the cost basis Payment ProceduresPayment ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/payment-procedures establishes for allowances, and no allowance adjustment shall carry a markup beyond what that basis allows.
11 Adjustment of the Contract Time
11.1 Request for Extension
11.1.1 A request for an extension of the Contract Time shall be made as a change proposal or as a claim under this standard, within the claim notice period indicated in the datasheet after the delaying event begins, and shall be supported by a time impact analysis.
11.1.2 A request for an extension of the Contract Time shall demonstrate, by the time impact analysis, that the delaying event delayed an activity on the critical path of the current accepted schedule and extended the scheduled date of substantial completion.
11.1.3 The number of days requested shall be the number of calendar days by which the time impact analysis shows the scheduled date of substantial completion extended, and not the duration of the delaying event.
NOTE A delay of ten days to an activity with twenty days of float delays the project by nothing, and a delay of ten days to a critical activity in a sequence that cannot be resequenced delays it by ten. The analysis is what tells the two apart, which is why the request is measured at the completion date and not at the event. The request is made when the delay begins, not when it ends, so that the Owner can act to mitigate it while there is still something to mitigate. (11.1.4)
11.2 Time Impact Analysis
11.2.1 The time impact analysis shall be a prospective analysis, prepared in the manner AACE International RP 52R-06 describes, that inserts the delaying event as a fragment of activities into the most recent schedule update accepted under Construction Progress DocumentationConstruction Progress DocumentationResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/construction-progress-documentation before the event, with the logic, the durations, and the progress of that update otherwise unchanged.
11.2.2 The time impact analysis shall identify the schedule update it is based on, the activities inserted and their logic ties, the activities whose durations or logic were changed and the reason, the critical path before and after the insertion, and the resulting change in the scheduled date of substantial completion.
11.2.3 Where the delaying event is continuing when the request is made, the time impact analysis shall be based on the Contractor's estimate of its duration, shall say so, and shall be updated when the event ends.
11.2.4 A request for an extension submitted without a time impact analysis, or with an analysis run on a schedule other than the most recent accepted update, shall be returned without action, and the time for the Engineer's response shall run from the submittal of a conforming analysis.
NOTE The schedule format, the software, the update interval, and the acceptance of each update are governed by Construction Progress DocumentationConstruction Progress DocumentationResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/construction-progress-documentation, and this standard assumes a schedule maintained under it. An analysis run on a schedule that was never accepted, or that was rebuilt for the analysis, proves whatever its author set out to prove, which is why the base is fixed at the last accepted update. The prospective analysis is required because it is the one that can be done while the delay is happening; the retrospective methods of RP 29R-03 are what a dispute falls back on when it was not. (11.2.5)
11.3 Concurrent Delay
11.3.1 Where a delay for which the Owner is responsible and a delay for which the Contractor is responsible affect the critical path over the same period, the adjustment of the Contract Time and of the Contract Sum shall be as the General Conditions provide, and the time impact analysis shall show each delay separately.
11.4 Weather Delay
11.4.1 A delay caused by weather shall be considered for an extension of the Contract Time on the basis indicated in the datasheet.
Weather Delay Basisradio
○ Abnormal weather, measured against anticipated adverse weather days stated by month in the Agreement or the Supplementary Conditions
○ Abnormal weather, measured against the published climatological normals of the nearest recording station
○ Weather delay not considered for an extension of the Contract Time
NOTE A stated table of anticipated adverse weather days per month is the basis that is easiest to apply: the Contractor is expected to lose those days and claims only the days beyond them, and the table is in the Contract before the bid. It depends on someone having prepared the table from local records. Measuring against the published normals of the nearest station gives the same comparison without a table, at the cost of a comparison that has to be drawn each month from the station's records, and of an argument about which station and which measure. Not considering weather at all puts the whole weather risk on the Contractor, who prices it, and it is the position of an Owner whose completion date is fixed by something outside the project, such as a regulatory deadline or a school year. (11.4.2)
11.4.3 Where weather delay is considered, the Contractor shall document each day claimed on the daily construction report under Construction Progress DocumentationConstruction Progress DocumentationResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/construction-progress-documentation, stating the weather condition, the activities prevented, and the hours lost, on the day it occurs.
11.4.4 Where weather delay is considered, a day shall count as a weather delay day only where the weather or its after-effects prevented work on an activity on the critical path for more than half of the scheduled working hours of that day.
11.4.5 A request for an extension for weather delay shall be made monthly, for the days claimed in the preceding month, and shall be supported by the daily construction reports and by the comparison with the baseline the datasheet indicates in place of a time impact analysis.
11.4.6 Any adjustment of the Contract Sum for a weather delay shall be as the General Conditions provide.
NOTE Weather is claimed monthly rather than by time impact analysis because a weather day is a lost working day on whatever was critical that day, and the arithmetic of days lost against days anticipated is the whole analysis. The half-day threshold and the critical-path condition are what keep a rain shower at noon on a day the crew was indoors from counting. (11.4.7)
12 Notice of Claims and Differing Site Conditions
12.1 Notice of a Claim
12.1.1 The Contractor shall give written notice of a claim to the Owner and the Engineer within the period indicated in the datasheet after the event giving rise to the claim occurs or the Contractor first recognizes the condition giving rise to it, whichever is later, and the Owner shall give written notice of a claim against the Contractor within the same period.
Claim Notice Periodrange
Not more than
days
135710142130
NOTE The General Conditions in common use each set a notice period for a claim, and the period in this field is required to match the one in the General Conditions on the project, because a shorter period here is overridden by the General Conditions and a longer one misleads the Contractor into a notice the General Conditions treat as late. Where the General Conditions set none, the period is set against how quickly the Owner needs to know to do anything about it: a short period lets the Owner observe the condition and mitigate the cost, and a long period gives the Contractor time to recognize that an event is a claim at all. The period runs from the event, or from recognition of the condition where the event is not obvious when it occurs. (12.1.2)
12.1.3 The notice of a claim shall identify the event or condition, the date it occurred or was recognized, the provision of the Contract Documents under which relief is claimed, the general nature of the relief, and, where the claim is for time, the activities affected.
12.1.4 The notice of a claim shall not be required to state the amount of the adjustment, and the Contractor shall submit the claim, with its cost breakdown under the Pricing of Changes section of this standard and its time impact analysis under the Adjustment of the Contract Time section where time is claimed, within the period the General Conditions set, or where they set none, within thirty days after the notice.
12.1.5 The notice the Contractor-Initiated Change Proposals section of this standard requires shall be the notice of a claim for the event it covers, and a second notice shall not be required for the same event.
12.2 Continuing Performance
12.2.1 The Contractor shall continue to perform the Work, and the Owner shall continue to make payments not in dispute, while a claim is pending, unless the General Conditions provide otherwise or the Owner directs in writing that the Work affected by the claim be suspended.
12.2.2 The Contractor shall keep, for the Work a claim covers, the daily records the Pricing of Changes section of this standard requires for force-account Work, from the date of the notice until the claim is resolved.
NOTE Stopping work over a claim converts a dispute about money into a dispute about delay, and the general conditions in common use require the Contractor to carry on. The records kept from the date of the notice are what the claim is eventually decided on, and a claim supported by records kept from the first day is settled; one reconstructed afterward is litigated. (12.2.3)
12.3 Hand-Off to the Dispute Resolution Procedure
12.3.1 The Engineer shall review a claim submitted under this standard and shall render the initial decision the General Conditions assign to it within the period the General Conditions set, or where they set none, within thirty days after receiving the substantiated claim or the further information the Engineer requests in writing within that period.
12.3.2 Where a claim is resolved by agreement, the resolution shall be recorded in a change order under this standard.
12.3.3 Where a party does not accept the Engineer's decision on a claim, the claim shall proceed under the dispute resolution procedure of the General Conditions, and this standard states nothing further about it.
NOTE This standard carries a claim to the point at which the Engineer has decided it, because up to that point the claim is administered with the same records, the same breakdown, and the same schedule analysis as a change. Beyond it, mediation, arbitration, and litigation are matters of the Agreement and the law of the jurisdiction, and a specification that tried to say anything about them would be ignored by the first lawyer to read it. (12.3.4)
12.4 Notice of a Differing Site Condition
12.4.1 The Contractor shall give written notice to the Owner and the Engineer within the period indicated in the datasheet after encountering a subsurface or concealed physical condition that differs materially from the conditions the Contract Documents indicate, or an unknown physical condition of an unusual nature that differs materially from the conditions ordinarily encountered in work of the character provided for, and before the condition is disturbed.
Differing Site Condition Notice Periodrange
Not more than
days
123571014
NOTE The notice period for a differing site condition is set short because the condition has to be seen before it is disturbed: an unsuitable stratum that has been excavated and hauled away, or a buried pipe that has been cut out and backfilled over, can no longer be examined by the Engineer, and the claim that depends on it rests on the Contractor's word. A period of one or two days suits a project with continuous excavation and an Engineer's representative on site, and a longer period suits one where the Engineer visits weekly and the Contractor would otherwise stop work waiting. The General Conditions on the project often state the period, and the field is required to match them where they do. (12.4.2)
12.4.3 The notice of a differing site condition shall identify the location, the condition encountered, the condition the Contract Documents indicated at that location, the date encountered, and the Work affected, and shall be accompanied by photographs of the condition before it is disturbed.
12.4.4 The Contractor shall not disturb a differing site condition, except as immediate safety requires, until the Engineer has observed it or has directed in writing that the Work proceed, and the Engineer shall observe the condition or so direct within two working days after the notice.
12.4.5 The Engineer shall investigate the condition, shall determine whether it differs materially from the conditions the Contract Documents indicate, and shall direct the response in writing, and where the condition is a subsurface condition the geotechnical investigation and the direction of the response shall be as EarthworkEarthworkResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/earthwork provides.
12.4.6 Where the Engineer determines that the condition differs materially and causes an increase or a decrease in the cost or the time of the Work, the adjustment shall be made by change order under this standard, and where the Engineer determines that it does not, the Contractor may pursue the matter as a claim under this standard.
12.4.7 Where the parties disagree whether a condition differs materially from the conditions the Contract Documents indicate, the Engineer shall make the initial determination, subject to the dispute resolution procedure of the General Conditions.
12.4.8 A condition the Contractor disturbed before giving notice, or before the Engineer had the opportunity to observe it, shall be the subject of an adjustment only to the extent the Engineer can verify the condition from the Contractor's photographs and records and from the Engineer's own investigation.
NOTE The differing site conditions clause in the general conditions exists so that bidders price the site the documents describe rather than the worst site they can imagine, and it works only if the Owner gets to see the condition that is said to differ. The notice period, the hold, and the photographs are the three things that make the condition verifiable; a Contractor who skips them has not lost the claim but has lost the evidence for it. (12.4.9)
13 Coordination with the Agreement and Other Standards
13.1 The Contractor shall reconcile the change, claim, and notice requirements of the Agreement, the General Conditions, and the Supplementary Conditions with this standard before the first proposal request is answered, and shall report in writing any conflict between them.
13.2 Where a technical standard and this standard address the same subject, the more stringent requirement shall govern unless the Contract Documents direct otherwise.
13.3 The Contractor shall include in each subcontract and purchase order the response time, cost breakdown, markup, force-account record, notice, and release requirements of this standard that apply to the subcontractor's or supplier's scope, and shall require each lower tier to give the Contractor the notices this standard requires in time for the Contractor to give its own.
NOTE A subcontractor's claim notice period that runs to the Contractor is worth nothing if it is longer than the Contractor's to the Owner. The flow-down, with the shorter period inside it, is what lets the Contractor pass the claim up in time, and the markup and breakdown requirements inside it are what let the Contractor demand of its subcontractor the breakdown the Owner will demand of it. (13.4)