SynC · Editorial revision

Product Requirements

Revision1
EditedNov 16, 2026
StatusCurrent
Contents

View changes in this revision   Revision history

Current revision. This is editorial revision 1, the current text of this standard. Read it on the standard's page.

New standard for how product options are read across every product standard: performance, reference standard, named manufacturers, basis of design or a single product. It separates a comparable product the Contractor proves from a substitution the Engineer must accept, and sets the substitution procedure, delivery, storage and handling.

1 Scope

NOTE This standard establishes the administrative requirements for the products furnished under the Contract: how the product options a section states are read, how a product other than the one named is proposed, judged, and accepted, how Owner-furnished products are received and installed, how the manufacturer's instructions bind the Work, and how every product is delivered, stored, and handled before it is incorporated, on any project and under any Division of the Specifications. (1.1)
NOTE A product standard states what a product has to be. This standard states what the Contractor is free to furnish in its place, who decides whether a proposed product is the specified one, what a departure from a specified value is called and how it is declared, and what happens to a product between the truck and the installation. Writing those rules once, here, keeps every product standard to the requirements particular to its product and keeps the rules from drifting apart between sections. (1.2)
NOTE The "or equal" and substitution provisions originate in the Agreement and the General Conditions, which are contract instruments, not specifications. A supplier or a subcontractor usually receives only the technical sections for its trade, so the party that proposes a different product has often never read the provision that governs the proposal. This standard carries the provision into the project manual, where every reader of a technical section finds it, and states the administrative detail those instruments leave open. (1.3)
1.4 The Contractor shall comply with this standard in addition to any product requirement stated in a product standard.
1.5 Where a product standard states a more stringent requirement for its product than this standard states, the product standard shall govern for that product.
1.6 Where a requirement of this standard conflicts with the Agreement, the General Conditions, or the Supplementary Conditions, those documents shall govern.
NOTE The following are outside the scope of this standard: (1.7)
  • The submittal register, the action and informational classification, and the transmittal and review workflow through which product data and comparable-product submittals move, and the disposition of nonconforming Work, which Submittal And Quality ProceduresSubmittal and Quality ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/submittal-and-quality-procedures governs
  • Testing, inspection, mockups, and quality control during construction, which Quality RequirementsQuality RequirementsResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/quality-requirements governs
  • The pre-bid substitution request window, the addenda that answer it, and the rest of the bidding phase, which Bidding ProceduresBidding ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/bidding-procedures governs; this standard states the content a pre-bid request carries and the rules by which it is judged
  • The change order, construction change directive, or other modification by which an accepted substitution is written into the Contract, which Contract Modification ProceduresContract Modification ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/contract-modification-procedures governs
  • Payment for products stored on or off the site before installation, which Payment ProceduresPayment ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/payment-procedures governs
  • Whether the project includes Owner-furnished products and which products they are, which Summary Of Work And Work RestrictionsSummary of Work and Work RestrictionsResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/summary-of-work-and-work-restrictions states; this standard governs the obligations once a product is Owner-furnished
  • Staging and storage areas, the site utilization plan, and temporary enclosures and heat for stored products, which Temporary Facilities And ControlsTemporary Facilities and ControlsResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/temporary-facilities-and-controls governs
  • Cutting and patching, protection of installed Work, progress cleaning, and starting and adjusting, which Execution RequirementsExecution RequirementsResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/execution-requirements governs
  • The warranty on a product, its form, and the claim procedure, which Warranties And BondsWarranties and BondsResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/warranties-and-bonds governs
  • The delivery, storage, and handling requirements particular to a product, which the governing product standard states in addition to this standard
  • The Agreement, the General Conditions, and the Supplementary Conditions, which this standard does not reproduce and which govern where it conflicts with them

2 Product Terms

NOTE The following terms are used in this standard with the meanings given here: (2.1)
  • A product is material, equipment, a system, an assembly, or a fabrication, whether purchased or made for the project, that is incorporated into the Work, together with the accessories the manufacturer requires for it to perform as specified
  • The basis of design is the product a section names, by manufacturer and by model or designation, as the one around which the design was prepared, and it stands for the quality, the features, the performance, the dimensions, and the arrangement the design assumes
  • A named manufacturer is a manufacturer a section lists as one whose product is acceptable, provided the product meets every other requirement of the section
  • A product option is the range of products a section admits, which depends on the method by which the section specifies: by performance, by a reference standard, by a list of named manufacturers, by a basis of design with comparable products, or by a single proprietary product
  • "Or equal", and the phrases "or approved equal", "or equivalent", and "comparable products permitted", mean that a section naming a product admits a comparable product, and the judgment of equality is the Engineer's
  • A comparable product is a product other than the basis of design, or from a manufacturer not named, that meets every requirement of the section, including every datasheet value read as the Datasheet Values article provides, and that the Engineer judges equal to the specified product in the characteristics the section states; furnishing one is the Contractor's choice within the specified options and requires no modification to the Contract
  • A substitution is a product, material, equipment, or method the Contractor proposes that lies outside the options a section admits: a product that departs from a specified value or characteristic, a product in place of a single proprietary product, a product of a manufacturer not named where no comparable product is admitted, or a method in place of a specified method; a substitution is accepted only in writing and is a change to the Contract Documents
  • A deviation is a departure, in a proposed product, from a value or a characteristic the section states, whether the departure is below, above, or beside the stated value
  • A substitution for cause is one made necessary by a condition the Contractor did not create, as the Substitutions for Cause article lists
  • A substitution for convenience is one the Contractor proposes for its own benefit, in cost, in schedule, or in method, where no cause exists
  • An Owner-furnished product is a product the Owner purchases and delivers to the site for the Contractor to receive, store, and install
  • The manufacturer's instructions are the manufacturer's published written directions for the storage, handling, installation, startup, adjustment, and maintenance of its product, in the edition current on the date of the product's action submittal

3 Referenced Standards

3.1 The product options, substitutions, and product handling under the Contract shall comply with the latest adopted edition of each of the following unless a specific edition is cited or the Contract Documents direct otherwise.
3.2 Where referenced documents conflict, the more stringent requirement shall govern unless the Engineer of Record directs otherwise in writing.
Standard Title
AIA A201 General Conditions of the Contract for Construction
AIA A701 Instructions to Bidders
EJCDC C-700 Standard General Conditions of the Construction Contract
EJCDC C-200 Instructions to Bidders for Construction Contract
ConsensusDocs 200 Standard Agreement and General Conditions Between Owner and Constructor
NOTE The general conditions in common use each carry an "or equal" provision and a substitution provision, and they differ in whether the Engineer's judgment of equality is final, in whether a substitute is accepted by a written notice or only by a change order, in who bears the Engineer's cost of evaluating a request, and in whether the Contractor's responsibility for an accepted substitute is stated or implied. The instructions to bidders in common use state whether a substitution is entertained before bid and how a bidder asks. This standard states the administrative detail those documents leave open, and where they settle a point differently, they govern. Public procurement law in many jurisdictions requires that a product named in a public contract be followed by an "or equal" provision, or bars a proprietary specification without a stated justification, and where such a law binds the Owner it governs over any selection in this standard. (3.3)

4 Submittals

4.1 Product Submittals

4.1.1 The Contractor shall submit the following, each at the time this standard states for it:
  • The product list, within the time indicated in the Product List article after the notice to proceed, naming for each section the manufacturer and the model or designation of each product the Contractor intends to furnish and identifying each as the basis of design, a named manufacturer's product, a comparable product, or a proposed substitution
  • The comparable-product submittal, with the action submittal for the product, containing the field-by-field comparison the Comparable Products section requires
  • The substitution request, on the form indicated in the datasheet and with the content the Substitution Request Content article requires, within the window the Substitutions section allows
  • The receiving report for each Owner-furnished delivery, at receipt and as the Owner-Furnished Products section requires
Product Submittals Requiredcheckbox
☑ Product list
☑ Comparable-product submittal with field-by-field comparison
☑ Substitution request on the indicated form
☑ Receiving report for Owner-furnished deliveries
4.1.2 Product submittals shall be transmitted and tracked through the submittal procedure of Submittal And Quality ProceduresSubmittal and Quality ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/submittal-and-quality-procedures, and the product data, shop drawings, and samples for a product shall be as that standard and the governing product standard require.
4.1.3 The substitution request shall be made on the form indicated in the datasheet.
Substitution Request Formradio
○ The Owner's form bound in the Contract Documents
○ Any written request containing the content this standard requires
NOTE A bound form puts every request in the same order, with the same representations signed in the same place, so that the Engineer reviews the comparison and not the letter, and it is what a public Owner with a standing program usually binds. Accepting any written request with the stated content spares a project the form and leaves the Engineer to check each request for the content it omits, which on a request for a small product is a letter and on a request for a process unit is a package. Either way the content is the same, since the form only arranges it. (4.1.4)

4.2 Product List

4.2.1 The Contractor shall submit the product list within the time indicated in the datasheet after the notice to proceed.
Product List Submission Time After Notice to Proceedrange
Not more than
days
1530456090
NOTE The product list is where a project learns, before the first submittal, which sections will come in as the basis of design, which as comparable products, and which as substitutions, and it is what lets the Engineer plan the review and the Owner see a proposed substitution before the product is on order. A short period produces a list the Contractor has not yet priced with its subcontractors and that changes, and a long period produces a list that arrives after the long-lead submittals it was meant to precede. The period is set against the procurement schedule of the Work, and a project with a long-lead process unit needs the list before that unit's submittal. (4.2.2)
4.2.3 The product list shall not be read as an action submittal for any product on it, and a product named on the list is subject to the action submittal the governing product standard requires.
4.2.4 A product identified on the product list as a proposed substitution shall be the subject of a substitution request, and listing it shall not constitute a request.

5 Product Options and the Reading Rule

5.1 How a Section Specifies a Product

NOTE A section specifies a product by one of five methods, and the method sets what the Contractor is free to furnish. A performance specification states what the product has to do and leaves the product to the Contractor. A reference standard specification names a consensus standard and a grade or class within it, and any product that conforms is the specified product. A list of named manufacturers admits any listed manufacturer's product that meets the rest of the section. A basis of design names one product and admits a comparable product on the Engineer's judgment. A single proprietary product admits that product alone. Most sections combine the methods, naming a basis of design and stating performance and a reference standard beside it, and under this standard each method applies to the part of the section written in it. (5.1.1)
5.1.2 Under a performance specification, the Contractor may furnish any product that meets every performance requirement the section states, and the Contractor shall furnish, with the action submittal, the test data, the certification, or the calculation that demonstrates conformance.
5.1.3 Under a reference standard specification, the Contractor may furnish any product that conforms to the referenced standard in the grade, class, or type the section states, and the Contractor shall furnish, with the action submittal, the manufacturer's certification of conformance to that standard.
5.1.4 Under a list of named manufacturers, the Contractor may furnish the product of any named manufacturer that meets every other requirement of the section, and a product of a manufacturer not named shall be a comparable product where the section admits one and a substitution where it does not.
5.1.5 Under a basis of design, the Contractor may furnish the basis of design product or a comparable product, and a comparable product shall be furnished only as the Comparable Products section provides.
5.1.6 Under a single proprietary product, the Contractor shall furnish that product, and any other product shall be a substitution.
NOTE A section specifies a single proprietary product where the design depends on that product and no other: a part that has to match equipment the Owner already operates, a component inside a listed assembly whose listing names it, a product the Owner has standardized on across its facilities for spare parts and training, or a product for which no second source exists. The specification states the reason beside the product where a public Owner's procurement law requires one, and a Contractor that reads a proprietary specification as a basis of design with the "or equal" left off has read it wrong. (5.1.7)

5.2 Reading a Named Product Without a Stated Option

5.2.1 Where a section names a manufacturer and a product and states neither that comparable products are admitted nor that none are, the named product shall be read as indicated in the datasheet.
Reading of a Named Product Without a Stated Optionradio
● Basis of design, with comparable products admitted
○ Proprietary product, with no other product except by accepted substitution
NOTE Reading an unqualified product name as a basis of design is what public procurement law requires in most jurisdictions and what most private Owners accept, and it means a section that forgot the phrase still admits competition. Reading it as proprietary gives the Owner the named product in every section that did not say otherwise, which an Owner standardizing a facility wants, at the cost of a bid priced on single sources and, on public work, of a specification the procurement law does not always allow. The reading applies only where the section is silent; a section that states its option governs. (5.2.2)
5.2.3 Where a section states that no substitutions are permitted for a product, or names a product as proprietary, that statement shall govern over the datasheet reading.

5.3 Datasheet Values and Deviations

5.3.1 A value in a section's datasheet shall be read as the value stated, subject to the manufacturing tolerance the referenced product standard allows, unless the datasheet states the value as a minimum or as a maximum.
5.3.2 A datasheet value stated as a minimum shall admit any product at or above the stated value, and a value stated as a maximum shall admit any product at or below it.
5.3.3 Where no referenced standard states a manufacturing tolerance for a value, the manufacturer's published tolerance for the product shall apply, and where none is published, the Engineer shall determine the tolerance on the Contractor's written request before the action submittal.
5.3.4 A proposed product that departs from a datasheet value, in either direction, departs from the Contract Documents, and a product that exceeds a value stated without direction is a deviation and not conformance.
NOTE A bare number is read by the law as the number, and the Owner is entitled to what the Contract says and not to what the supplier considers as good or better. The datasheets in this library carry the direction on each value for that reason: a value marked as a minimum is the Engineer's decision, made in advance, that more is harmless, and a value left exact is the Engineer's decision that more has consequences, such as a larger frame that does not fit the enclosure, a different trip characteristic that breaks the coordination study, a bigger motor on a feeder sized for the smaller one, or a coating thickness at the top of a tolerance stack. The direction on the value is the Engineer's answer to the question the supplier would otherwise ask after shipment. (5.3.5)
5.3.6 The Contractor shall identify in writing, on the transmittal and on the submittal itself, every deviation in a proposed product from a value or a characteristic the section states.
5.3.7 The Engineer's review of a submittal shall not accept a deviation the Contractor did not identify in writing, and the Contractor shall remain responsible for furnishing the specified value or characteristic regardless of the review action.
5.3.8 Where the Contractor identifies a deviation on a comparable-product submittal and the Engineer determines that the deviation changes no other Work and no cost or time, the Engineer may accept the deviation in writing on the submittal, and a deviation the Engineer does not so accept shall be the subject of a substitution request.
NOTE A deviation that is not called out is the one that reaches the field, because a reviewer checking a forty-page submittal against a section reads for what the Contractor says it is furnishing and not for what it quietly is not. The call-out costs the Contractor a line on the transmittal and buys it a written answer; without it, the review stamp proves nothing and the Contractor furnishes the specified value at its own cost when the departure is found. (5.3.9)
5.3.10 Where the Contractor finds a datasheet value ambiguous as to its direction, the Contractor shall ask through the request for information procedure before bid where the ambiguity is apparent in the bid documents, and otherwise before the action submittal, and shall not resolve the ambiguity by furnishing the product it prefers.

6 Comparable Products

6.1 Comparable-Product Submittal

6.1.1 Requirements in this section apply where a section admits a comparable product and the Contractor proposes one.
6.1.2 The Contractor shall furnish, with the action submittal for a comparable product, a field-by-field comparison of the proposed product against every requirement of the section, listing each datasheet value, each stated characteristic, and each referenced standard beside the proposed product's value or characteristic for the same item, and identifying every deviation.
6.1.3 The comparison shall include the manufacturer's product data for the proposed product, the evidence of conformance the section requires for the specification method under which the product is specified, and a statement of every change to other Work, including rough-in, connections, supports, clearances, and controls, that the proposed product requires.
6.1.4 A comparable product shall be of a manufacturer that has produced the product, in the size and type proposed, for the period and in the quantity the governing product standard requires for manufacturer qualification, and where the product standard states none, for not less than five years.
6.1.5 The Contractor shall bear the cost of every change to other Work that a comparable product requires, and the Contract Sum and the Contract Time shall not be adjusted for a comparable product.
NOTE A comparable product is the Contractor's choice inside the options the section already admits, which is why it comes through the ordinary action submittal and not through a substitution request, and why the Owner pays nothing for it. The comparison is what makes it reviewable: a product data sheet alone tells the Engineer what the product is, and the comparison tells the Engineer what the Contractor claims it matches and where the Contractor knows it does not. (6.1.6)

6.2 The Engineer's Judgment of Equality

6.2.1 The Engineer shall judge whether a proposed comparable product is equal to the specified product on the characteristics the section states, including every datasheet value, the performance stated, the referenced standards, the construction and the materials, the features and the accessories, the dimensions and the arrangement where other Work depends on them, the warranty, and the availability of service and parts.
6.2.2 A proposed product that lacks a characteristic the section states shall not be judged equal on the ground that it carries a different characteristic the Contractor considers better.
6.2.3 The Engineer's judgment of equality shall be final for the purpose of the submittal review, subject to the dispute resolution provisions of the Contract Documents.
6.2.4 Where the Engineer rejects a proposed comparable product, the Engineer shall state in writing the characteristic or the value on which the product was found not equal.
6.2.5 Where the Engineer accepts a proposed comparable product, the acceptance shall extend only to the characteristics the comparison stated, and shall not relieve the Contractor of any requirement of the Contract Documents, of responsibility for the product's performance, or of responsibility for its fit with other Work.
NOTE A stated reason is what separates a rejection the Contractor can answer from one it can only contest. An Engineer that evaluates the product and writes down the characteristic it lacks has exercised the judgment the Contract gives it, and that judgment holds; an Engineer that declines to evaluate, or rejects without a reason, has not, and a Contractor that offered a product meeting the stated requirements then has a claim. The reason costs the Engineer a sentence and is the sentence the dispute turns on. (6.2.6)
6.2.7 The Engineer's time to review a comparable-product submittal shall be the review period for an action submittal under Submittal And Quality ProceduresSubmittal and Quality ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/submittal-and-quality-procedures.

7 Substitutions

7.1 When Substitutions Are Entertained

7.1.1 The Owner shall entertain substitution requests in the circumstances indicated in the datasheet and in no others.
Substitution Requests Entertainedcheckbox
Any of:
☑ Before bid, through the bidding procedure
☑ During construction, for cause
☐ During construction, for the Contractor's convenience
NOTE The three circumstances are independent and a project selects any combination. Entertaining requests before bid lets every bidder price the same accepted product and keeps the competition at the bid table, at the cost of an addendum cycle in the bidding period; it is the circumstance nearly every project allows. Entertaining requests for cause during construction is what keeps a project moving when the specified product is discontinued, fails, or is outlawed between bid and installation, and the causes are listed so that a change of mind is not one of them. Entertaining requests for convenience during construction opens the project to proposals the Contractor finds cheaper or faster after award, which brings the Owner a credit and the Engineer a review it did not plan, and an Owner that wants a fixed design after award leaves it unselected. A project that selects none has told the Contractor that the specified products are the Work. (7.1.2)
7.1.3 A substitution request made outside the circumstances indicated in the datasheet shall be returned without review.
7.1.4 The Contractor shall not order, fabricate, deliver, or install a substitution before the Owner's written acceptance of it, and a substitution installed without acceptance is nonconforming Work subject to Submittal And Quality ProceduresSubmittal and Quality ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/submittal-and-quality-procedures.

7.2 Pre-Bid Substitutions

7.2.1 Requirements in this article apply where substitution requests before bid are indicated in the datasheet.
7.2.2 A pre-bid substitution request shall be made within the request window, and shall be answered by addendum, as Bidding ProceduresBidding ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/bidding-procedures provides.
7.2.3 A pre-bid substitution request shall carry the content the Substitution Request Content article requires, and shall be judged by the criteria the Judgment of a Substitution Request article states.
7.2.4 A substitution accepted before bid shall be accepted by addendum, and a product not named in an addendum or in the bid documents shall not be a specified product, regardless of any response the Engineer gave the bidder in another form.
NOTE The addendum is what reaches every bidder. A letter to one bidder accepting its product gives that bidder a price advantage the others cannot see, and it is the letter the losing bidder protests. The bidding procedure is written so that the only accepted answer is the one issued to all, and this standard holds the Contractor to it after award: a product the bidder believed was accepted, and that no addendum names, is a substitution during construction and is judged as one. (7.2.5)

7.3 Substitutions for Cause

7.3.1 Requirements in this article apply where substitution requests for cause are indicated in the datasheet.
7.3.2 A substitution request for cause shall be made only for one of the following causes, which the Contractor did not create and could not reasonably have discovered before bid:
  • The specified product is unavailable within the Contract Time, through no fault of the Contractor, because it has been discontinued, because the manufacturer cannot deliver it, or because of an event beyond the Contractor's control
  • A code, a regulation, or an authority having jurisdiction, by a change after the bid date or by an interpretation first issued after it, prohibits the specified product or requires a product the specified one is not
  • The specified product has failed in service on this project or has been withdrawn by its manufacturer, or the manufacturer declines to furnish the warranty the Contract Documents require for it
  • The specified product cannot be made to perform as specified because of a condition of the Work that the Contract Documents did not disclose, and the Engineer has confirmed the condition in writing
  • The specified product conflicts with another requirement of the Contract Documents, and the Engineer has confirmed in writing that the conflict cannot be resolved without a change of product
7.3.3 The Contractor shall submit a substitution request for cause within fourteen days after the Contractor learns of the cause, and shall state in the request the date the cause arose and the date the Contractor learned of it.
NOTE The causes are the events a prudent Contractor cannot price: a discontinuation, a new code, a failure, a condition in the ground. Each is outside the Contractor's control, and a request founded on one is answered on the merits of the proposed product and not on whether the Contractor wanted the change. A product the Contractor finds expensive, slow, or hard to get from its usual supplier is not unavailable, and a request on that ground is a request for convenience, entertained only where the datasheet admits one. (7.3.4)
7.3.5 Where a substitution for cause is accepted, the Contract Sum shall be adjusted for the difference in cost, up or down, only where the cause is one for which the Contract Documents place the risk on the Owner, and otherwise the Contractor shall bear any increase and shall credit any decrease.

7.4 Substitutions for Convenience

7.4.1 Requirements in this article apply where substitution requests for the Contractor's convenience are indicated in the datasheet.
7.4.2 The Contractor shall submit a substitution request for convenience within the time indicated in the datasheet after the notice to proceed, and a request submitted after that time shall be returned without review.
Convenience Substitution Request Window After Notice to Proceedrange
Not more than
days
1530456090120
NOTE A short window confines convenience requests to the period before the submittals are under way, when a change of product costs the Engineer a review and nothing else, and it is what a project with a tight design, such as a plant with a fixed hydraulic profile, usually sets. A long window lets the Contractor propose a product it discovered while buying out the subcontracts, which is when most savings are found, at the cost of requests that arrive after the rough-in for the specified product is drawn and sometimes built. The window is measured from the notice to proceed because that is the date every bidder knows at award. (7.4.3)
7.4.4 The Contractor shall credit the Owner, through the modification that accepts the substitution, the share indicated in the datasheet of the net saving in the Contractor's cost that the substitution produces, after the Contractor's cost of the changes to other Work the substitution requires.
Owner's Share of a Convenience Substitution Savingrange
% of the net saving
255075100
NOTE Crediting the Owner the whole saving is the arrangement under which a convenience substitution changes the product and nothing in the Contractor's margin, and it is the arrangement most general conditions imply when they say the Contract Sum is adjusted for the change. Sharing the saving gives the Contractor a reason to look for one, which is the premise of a value engineering clause, and where the Agreement carries such a clause it sets the share and this field follows it. A share of zero leaves the whole saving with the Contractor and is selected by an Owner that wants the Contractor to buy out aggressively and does not want to review the Contractor's cost to find the credit. (7.4.5)
7.4.6 The Contractor shall state in a convenience substitution request the net saving it proposes to credit, with the cost breakdown that supports it, and the Owner's acceptance shall be conditioned on the credit stated.

7.5 Substitution Request Content

7.5.1 Each substitution request shall identify the section, the specified product, and the proposed product by manufacturer and model or designation, and shall state which circumstance indicated in the datasheet the request is made under and, for a request for cause, the cause.
7.5.2 Each substitution request shall include the manufacturer's product data for the proposed product and the field-by-field comparison the Comparable Products section requires, listing every deviation from the specified product.
7.5.3 Each substitution request shall state every effect of the proposed product on other Work, including on dimensions and clearances, on rough-in and connections, on structural supports, on electrical loads and circuits, on controls and sequences, on the schedule of other trades, and on Work already in place, and shall identify every drawing and section the change affects.
7.5.4 Each substitution request shall state the effect of the proposed product on the Contract Sum and on the Contract Time, with the cost breakdown Contract Modification ProceduresContract Modification ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/contract-modification-procedures requires for a change proposal, including the credit for a substitution for convenience.
7.5.5 Each substitution request shall state the warranty the manufacturer and the Contractor will furnish for the proposed product and shall identify every respect in which it differs from the warranty the Contract Documents require.
7.5.6 Each substitution request shall include the Contractor's representation, signed by the Contractor, that the Contractor has investigated the proposed product and determined that it is equal to or better than the specified product in every characteristic the section states, except for the deviations the request identifies; that the Contractor will furnish the same warranty for the substitution as for the specified product unless the request states otherwise; that the Contractor will coordinate the substitution with every affected trade and bear the cost of the changes to other Work it requires; and that the Contractor waives any claim for an addition to the Contract Sum or the Contract Time arising from the substitution's failure to perform as represented.
7.5.7 Each substitution request shall include, where the proposed product is used on another project in service, the name and the location of that project and the Owner's contact there, and where the governing product standard requires an installation list for manufacturer qualification, the list.
NOTE The representation is the part of the request a Contractor signs without reading and the part the Owner relies on when the substitute does not work. It puts on the Contractor, who chose the product, the investigation the Engineer cannot make from a data sheet, and it makes the Contractor's claim that the product is equal a statement the Contractor stands behind rather than a sales assertion forwarded from the supplier. A request without it is a request the Owner is being asked to underwrite. (7.5.8)

7.6 Judgment of a Substitution Request

7.6.1 The Engineer shall review each substitution request and shall recommend to the Owner acceptance or rejection within the time indicated in the datasheet after receiving a complete request, and the Owner shall accept or reject the request in writing.
Substitution Request Review Periodrange
Not more than
days
71014152130
NOTE Fourteen days is the period most project manuals set, and it is what an Engineer with the section and the comparison in hand needs to check a product and consult the Owner. A shorter period suits a project in a hurry and is met only on a simple product; a longer period is set where the substitute is a process unit whose acceptance needs a hydraulic or electrical check across other sections, and on such a request the Engineer states the longer period on receipt. The period runs from a complete request, so an incomplete one does not start the clock. (7.6.2)
7.6.3 A substitution request that omits any content the Substitution Request Content article requires shall be returned as incomplete, with the omission identified, and the review period shall run from the complete resubmission.
7.6.4 The Engineer shall judge a substitution request by whether the proposed product meets the characteristics the section states, including every datasheet value as read under the Datasheet Values article, and, for each deviation the request identifies, by whether the deviation is acceptable to the design, to the Owner's operation and maintenance of the facility, and to the other Work it affects.
7.6.5 The Owner may reject a substitution request without stating a reason where the request is for convenience, and shall state the reason for rejecting a request made for cause or before bid.
7.6.6 Where the Engineer and the Owner disagree on a substitution, the Owner's decision shall govern, and the Engineer shall record in writing any deviation accepted over the Engineer's recommendation.
NOTE A substitution for cause is one the Contractor cannot avoid, so the Owner owes it an answer on the merits and a reason when the answer is no; a substitution for convenience is a proposal the Owner was free to decline before it was made, and remains free to decline after. The recorded disagreement between the Engineer and the Owner is for the day the accepted deviation matters, so that the record shows who accepted it and that the Engineer advised against it. (7.6.7)
7.6.8 A substitution request shall not be the subject of a request for information, and a request for information proposing a different product shall be returned with direction to submit a substitution request.
7.6.9 The Contractor may submit one substitution request for a product, and a second request for the same product shall be entertained only where it cures the deviation on which the first was rejected or is founded on a cause that arose after the first.
7.6.10 Where the Owner accepts a substitution on stated conditions, the conditions shall be part of the acceptance, and a substitution furnished without meeting them shall be a substitution furnished without acceptance.

7.7 Acceptance and Its Effect

7.7.1 A substitution shall be accepted only by a written acceptance signed by the Owner or by a modification to the Contract Documents, and no submittal review action, meeting minute, verbal statement, or course of conduct shall constitute acceptance.
7.7.2 Where an accepted substitution changes the Contract Sum or the Contract Time, or requires a change to the drawings or to another section, the acceptance shall be written into the Contract by the modification procedure of Contract Modification ProceduresContract Modification ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/contract-modification-procedures, and where it changes neither, the Owner's written acceptance shall suffice.
7.7.3 An accepted substitution shall not relieve the Contractor of any requirement of the Contract Documents that the acceptance does not expressly waive, and the Contractor shall furnish the substitution in conformance with every requirement of the section other than the deviations the acceptance names.
7.7.4 The Contractor shall bear the cost of every change to other Work that an accepted substitution requires, including the Work of other contractors and of the Owner's separate contractors, and shall coordinate the change with every affected trade.
7.7.5 The costs of the Engineer's redesign and added services caused by an accepted substitution shall be borne as indicated in the datasheet.
Engineer's Redesign and Added Services for an Accepted Substitutionradio
○ Borne by the Contractor in full, including review of the request and redesign of affected Work
○ Borne by the Contractor for redesign of affected Work only
NOTE An accepted substitution costs the Engineer time twice, once to review the request and once to redraw the Work the product changes, and the Owner pays the Engineer for both under the Agreement between them unless the Contract passes the cost through. Charging the Contractor the whole of it makes the Contractor price a substitution against its full cost to the project and is the arrangement a public Owner whose design fee is fixed usually requires; it also makes a Contractor reluctant to propose a substitution for cause, which is a substitution the Owner wants to hear about. Charging the Contractor the redesign alone treats the review as part of the Engineer's ordinary services and the redesign as the consequence of the Contractor's choice, which is the division most general conditions in common use describe. The Owner's position between them is a matter of its fee arrangement with the Engineer and of how many substitutions it expects to see. (7.7.6)
7.7.7 Where the Contractor bears the Engineer's costs, the Owner may deduct them from sums due the Contractor on the Engineer's invoice, and the Contractor shall be furnished a copy of the invoice.
7.7.8 Where an accepted substitution fails to perform as the Contractor represented, the Contractor shall, at its own cost, replace it with the specified product or with another accepted substitution, and shall bear the cost of the changes to other Work the replacement requires.
7.7.9 The Contractor shall carry each accepted substitution onto the record documents under Operation And Maintenance DataOperation and Maintenance DataResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/operation-and-maintenance-data, identifying the specified product it replaced and the modification that accepted it.

8 Owner-Furnished Products

8.1 Owner's Obligations

8.1.1 Requirements in this section apply to each product that Summary Of Work And Work RestrictionsSummary of Work and Work RestrictionsResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/summary-of-work-and-work-restrictions identifies as Owner-furnished.
8.1.2 The Owner shall furnish to the Contractor, before the Contractor's rough-in for the product, the product data, the shop drawings, the dimensions, the weights, the utility requirements, and the manufacturer's instructions for each Owner-furnished product.
8.1.3 The Owner shall arrange and pay for the delivery of each Owner-furnished product to the site, on the dates the Contractor's progress schedule designates and the Owner has confirmed in writing, and shall notify the Contractor of a change in a delivery date not less than seven days before the earlier of the two dates.
8.1.4 The Owner shall inspect each delivery jointly with the Contractor, shall submit any claim for damage in transit to the carrier and the supplier, and shall arrange for the repair or the replacement of a product damaged in transit or found defective at receipt.
8.1.5 The Owner shall obtain the manufacturer's warranty on each Owner-furnished product, and the Contractor's warranty under Warranties And BondsWarranties and BondsResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/warranties-and-bonds shall cover the Contractor's installation of the product and not the product itself.
NOTE An Owner-furnished product reaches the site without a submittal having passed through the Contractor, so the Contractor is building the rough-in to information it did not produce. The Owner's obligation to furnish the product data before the rough-in is the obligation that makes the Contractor's coordination possible, and a product that arrives with no drawings is roughed in to assumptions and then moved. (8.1.6)

8.2 Contractor's Obligations

8.2.1 The Contractor shall designate in its progress schedule the date each Owner-furnished product is required at the site, shall confirm the date with the Owner in writing not less than thirty days before it, and shall review the Owner's product data for each product and report in writing, before the rough-in, every conflict between the product and the Work prepared to receive it.
8.2.2 The Contractor shall receive, unload, and handle each Owner-furnished product at the site, using the equipment and the methods the manufacturer's instructions require, and shall furnish the labor, the equipment, and the rigging for it.
8.2.3 The Contractor shall inspect each Owner-furnished delivery jointly with the Owner at receipt, shall count it against the shipping documents, and shall record on the receiving report, before signing the carrier's receipt, every shortage and every visible damage.
8.2.4 The Contractor shall report in writing to the Owner, within seven days after unpacking an Owner-furnished product, any damage or shortage the packaging concealed at receipt.
8.2.5 Damage and shortage recorded at receipt, and concealed damage reported within the seven days, shall be the Owner's responsibility, and damage and shortage not so recorded or reported shall be the Contractor's.
8.2.6 After receipt, the Contractor shall store, protect, and handle each Owner-furnished product as the Delivery, Storage, and Handling section and the manufacturer's instructions require, and shall be responsible for the product until substantial completion as if the Contractor had furnished it.
8.2.7 The Contractor shall repair or replace, at its own cost, an Owner-furnished product that is lost, stolen, or damaged after receipt, by a product of the same manufacturer and model or by one the Owner accepts in writing.
8.2.8 The Contractor shall install, connect, start, and adjust each Owner-furnished product as the manufacturer's instructions and the governing product standard require, and the Work of installing it shall be subject to every requirement of the Contract Documents that would apply had the Contractor furnished it.
NOTE The receiving report is the line between the Owner's risk and the Contractor's. Before the signature on the carrier's receipt, a damaged crate is the carrier's problem and the Owner's claim; after it, the same crate is in the Contractor's custody and the carrier has a signed receipt saying it arrived whole. The joint inspection and the written record at the dock are what make the line enforceable, and the seven days for concealed damage are there because a pump arrives in a box nobody opens until the pad is poured. (8.2.9)

9 Manufacturer's Instructions

9.1 Compliance and Conflicts

9.1.1 The Contractor shall store, handle, install, connect, start, adjust, and protect each product in accordance with the manufacturer's instructions, in addition to the requirements of the Contract Documents.
9.1.2 Where the Contract Documents state a requirement more stringent than the manufacturer's instructions, the Contract Documents shall govern.
9.1.3 Where the manufacturer's instructions conflict with the Contract Documents, or where following the Contract Documents would void the manufacturer's warranty or a product listing, the Contractor shall notify the Engineer in writing before proceeding with the affected Work and shall proceed only as the Engineer directs.
9.1.4 Where the manufacturer's instructions and the Contract Documents are both silent on a matter of installation, the Contractor shall install the product in accordance with the practice the referenced standards for the product describe, and where those are silent, as the Engineer directs on the Contractor's written request.
NOTE The manufacturer's instructions are written for the product and the Contract Documents for the project, and when they disagree, each is right about the thing it was written for. A manufacturer's instruction that would place a valve where the drawings place a wall is a conflict the Engineer has to resolve, and a Contractor that picks one and proceeds has made a design decision it was not asked to make. The notice before proceeding is what keeps that decision with the Engineer, and the warranty and listing clause is there because a warranty voided by an installation the Contract required is a warranty the Owner paid for and does not have. (9.1.5)
9.1.6 The Contractor shall keep a copy of the manufacturer's instructions for each product at the site, in the edition the product's action submittal carried, from the product's delivery until its installation is accepted, and shall make the copy available to the Engineer and to the Owner on request.
9.1.7 Where a manufacturer's instruction requires an installer trained, certified, or licensed by the manufacturer, or requires the attendance of the manufacturer's representative at installation or startup, the Contractor shall furnish it, and the governing product standard shall state any requirement beyond the manufacturer's.

10 Standard of Quality

10.1 New Products and Currency

10.1.1 Every product incorporated into the Work shall be new, of current production, and undamaged at the time of installation, unless the Contract Documents identify a salvaged, reused, or remanufactured product for a stated location.
10.1.2 A product that the manufacturer has discontinued, or has announced for discontinuation before the date of the action submittal, shall not be furnished unless the Engineer accepts it in writing with the manufacturer's written commitment to parts and service for the period the governing product standard requires.
NOTE A product of current production is one the manufacturer will still support when the first part fails, and a discontinued model offered at a discount is the model whose spare parts are unavailable in year three. A section that names a model the manufacturer has since replaced is answered by a substitution request for cause, not by furnishing the old model from a distributor's shelf without saying so. (10.1.3)
10.1.4 Where the Contract Documents identify a salvaged or reused product, the Contractor shall furnish it in the condition the governing section states, and otherwise clean, in working order, and complete with the accessories the section requires.

10.2 Compatibility of Products

10.2.1 The Contractor shall furnish products that are compatible with one another and with the materials they contact, and shall be responsible for selecting, among the options each section admits, products that are compatible across sections.
10.2.2 Where the compatibility of two products depends on a manufacturer's confirmation, such as a coating over a primer, a sealant against a membrane, or a controller with an actuator, the Contractor shall obtain the confirmation in writing from each manufacturer before the action submittal for the later product.
10.2.3 Where two products the Contract Documents specify cannot be made compatible under any option the sections admit, the Contractor shall notify the Engineer in writing before the action submittal for either, and the resolution shall be by the modification procedure of Contract Modification ProceduresContract Modification ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/contract-modification-procedures.
NOTE Compatibility is the requirement that falls between sections, because each section was written about its own product and the roofing section does not know which sealant the glazing section chose. The Contractor is the only party that selects both, and the obligation to select compatibly is placed on it for that reason, with the manufacturer's confirmation as the evidence, since a manufacturer that has not confirmed will disclaim the failure at the interface. (10.2.4)

10.3 Products of One Manufacturer for Like Items

10.3.1 Products of the same kind on the project shall be of one manufacturer as indicated in the datasheet.
Products of One Manufacturer for Like Itemsradio
● Required for each kind of product throughout the project
○ Required only where the governing product standard requires it
○ Not required
NOTE One manufacturer for every valve, every luminaire of a type, every door closer gives the Owner one spare parts inventory, one service contact, and one set of instructions per kind of product, and gives the Engineer one submittal to review per kind, at the cost of narrowing each kind to the manufacturer whose product the Contractor chose first, which a Contractor buying out trades separately does not always control. Leaving the requirement to each product standard confines it to the products where it matters, such as the valves in a plant or the hardware on a floor of doors, and relieves it where it does not, such as the fasteners. Not requiring it at all maximizes the Contractor's freedom to buy each lot where it is cheapest and leaves the Owner maintaining several makes of the same thing. On a public contract the requirement operates within each kind and does not narrow the competition between manufacturers for the kind. (10.3.2)
10.3.3 Where products of one manufacturer are required for a kind of product, the Contractor shall identify the manufacturer on the product list and shall furnish every product of that kind on the project, in every section, from that manufacturer, unless the Engineer accepts a second manufacturer in writing for a product the first does not make.
10.3.4 Where products of one manufacturer are not required, products of the same kind that are interchangeable in service, such as lamps of a type, filters of a size, or fuses of a class, shall be interchangeable across the project regardless of manufacturer.

10.4 Nameplates and Markings

10.4.1 Each product shall bear the manufacturer's nameplate or marking that the governing product standard, the referenced standards, and the listing or labeling for the product require, in a location readable after installation.
10.4.2 The manufacturer's name, trademark, or logo shall not be displayed on an exposed finished surface of the Work, other than on a nameplate the code or a listing requires, unless the governing product standard permits it.
10.4.3 Where Adopted Building CodeAdopted Building CodeParameterEach project supplies its own value.adopted-building-code or Adopted Electrical CodeAdopted Electrical CodeParameterEach project supplies its own value.adopted-electrical-code requires a product to be listed and labeled, the product shall bear the listing mark of a testing laboratory the authority having jurisdiction recognizes, and a product without the mark shall not be furnished on the strength of a manufacturer's statement of equivalence.
NOTE A listing is the laboratory's statement that the product it tested is the product in the box, and a field-modified or unlisted product carries no such statement. The authority having jurisdiction accepts the mark and not the data sheet, and a product that arrives without the mark is installed and then red-tagged, which is the most expensive way to discover it. (10.4.4)

11 Delivery, Storage, and Handling

11.1 Obligations Every Product Standard Inherits

11.1.1 Requirements in this section apply to every product on the project, and each product standard states the delivery, storage, and handling requirements particular to its product in addition to them; where the two conflict, the more stringent requirement shall govern.
11.1.2 The Contractor shall schedule each delivery in the sequence of the Work and so that the time a product is stored on the site before installation is the shortest the progress schedule allows, and shall not deliver a product to the site before a storage location meeting this section is available for it.
11.1.3 The Contractor shall deliver each product in the manufacturer's original, unopened packaging, bearing the manufacturer's label legible and intact, identifying the product, the manufacturer, the grade, type, or class, the lot or batch where the product has one, and the standard to which the product conforms where the label ordinarily carries it.
11.1.4 The Contractor shall inspect each delivery at receipt against the accepted submittal and the shipping documents, shall reject and remove from the site any product that is damaged, that is not the product the accepted submittal names, or that departs from the accepted submittal, and shall record the rejection and the replacement.
NOTE The inspection at delivery is the point at which the product furnished is compared with the product accepted, and it is the point Quality RequirementsQuality RequirementsResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/quality-requirements relies on when it requires that delivered products match the accepted submittals before incorporation. A product that passes through the gate unchecked is found in the field, built in, and the argument is then about removal rather than return. (11.1.5)

11.2 Storage and Protection

11.2.1 The Contractor shall store each product in accordance with the manufacturer's instructions, and where the manufacturer's instructions are silent, off the ground, under cover, dry, and protected from weather, sunlight, freezing, heat, contamination, and physical damage.
11.2.2 The Contractor shall store a product the manufacturer's instructions assign a temperature or humidity limit within that limit, in an enclosure heated or conditioned as needed, and the enclosure shall be furnished under Temporary Facilities And ControlsTemporary Facilities and ControlsResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/temporary-facilities-and-controls.
11.2.3 The Contractor shall store a product with a shelf life, a cure date, or an expiration date so that the date is visible, shall rotate stock so that the oldest is used first, and shall not incorporate a product past its date.
11.2.4 The Contractor shall store products in the staging and storage areas designated on the site utilization plan and shall not store products in a location that loads a structure beyond its design capacity, obstructs an exit, or interferes with the Owner's operations.
11.2.5 The Contractor shall store products inside the building or structure only after the enclosure protects them as the manufacturer's instructions require, and shall not store finish products, electrical equipment, or controls in a space that is not weathertight and dry.
11.2.6 The Contractor shall protect each stored product against theft, vandalism, and damage, and shall bear the cost of repairing or replacing a product lost or damaged in delivery, storage, or handling before substantial completion, whether the product is Contractor-furnished or Owner-furnished after receipt.
11.2.7 The Contractor shall handle each product with the equipment, the lifting points, and the methods the manufacturer's instructions require, and shall not drag, drop, or point-load a product, or lift it by a connection, a shaft, a flange, or a component not intended for lifting.
11.2.8 Equipment stored for more than the period the manufacturer's instructions allow without attention shall receive the manufacturer's long-term storage procedure, including rotation of shafts, energizing of space heaters, and renewal of preservatives, and the Contractor shall keep a log of each procedure performed.
NOTE A pump stored for a season without its shaft turned has a brinelled bearing on the day it starts, and the manufacturer's warranty excludes it. The long-term storage procedure is the manufacturer's own list of what keeps the warranty alive while the equipment waits, and the log is what proves it was followed when the bearing fails anyway. (11.2.9)

11.3 Inspection of Stored Products

11.3.1 The Owner and the Engineer may inspect any stored product, on or off the site, at any time during working hours, and the Contractor shall provide access.
11.3.2 A stored product found damaged, deteriorated, stored contrary to this section or to the manufacturer's instructions, or past its date shall be rejected regardless of any earlier acceptance of the submittal or of the delivery, and the Contractor shall remove and replace it at its own cost.
11.3.3 Where a product is stored off the site, the storage shall meet this section, the product shall be identified as the property of the project and segregated from other stock, and the Owner's inspection right shall extend to it; payment for the stored product shall be as Payment ProceduresPayment ProceduresResolves to the current adopted revision.sync/payment-procedures provides.
11.3.4 The Contractor shall deliver to the Owner, at substantial completion, every product the Contract Documents require to be delivered loose, including spare parts, extra stock, special tools, and keys, in the quantity and the packaging the governing product standard requires, with a transmittal the Owner signs on receipt.

12 Coordination with Product Standards

12.1 The Contractor shall reconcile the product option, substitution, and handling requirements of each product standard with this standard and shall report in writing, before the action submittal for the product, any conflict between them.
12.2 Where a product standard and this standard address the same subject, the more stringent requirement shall govern unless the Contract Documents direct otherwise.
12.3 The Contractor shall include in each subcontract and purchase order the product option, deviation, substitution, manufacturer's instructions, and delivery, storage, and handling requirements of this standard that apply to the subcontractor's or supplier's scope.
NOTE A supplier that never saw this standard, because its purchase order carried only the technical section for its product, ships the product it considers equal and learns of the deviation rule when the submittal is returned. Flowing the requirements into the purchase order is what makes the comparison and the deviation call-out the supplier's obligation before the product is built, rather than the Contractor's problem after it is shipped. (12.4)

Written and maintained by SynC. Licensed under CC BY 4.0.